Monday, August 12, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 111: Kate Chopin, A Morning Walk (#69)

Kate Chopin, "A Morning Walk" (1897) from Kate Chopin: Complete Novels & Stories:

Here's a short story, only four pages, and the original title gives some hint as to the plot in a way that the current title doesn't: “An Easter Day Conversion” clearly tells us this is a special event; "A Morning Walk" sounds like one of many. Maybe the new title lets the plot creep up on the reader?

In any case, it doesn't creep up slowly. From the first we meet Archibald, all we hear is that he seems older than he is; he's more practical and scientific than poetical and sentimental--"For he leaned decidedly toward practical science; of sentiment he knew little..."; and that he's pretty inattentive to women.

Except that's the first page; already by the second we're hearing that today feels different for him--now he's noticing beauty. So already, by page two, we have something of a conversion. Where do we go from here? Well, Chopin keeps us between these two states--between the practical man of page one and the sentimental man of page two.

Whenever Chopin wants to stress the sentimental--as she does when Archibald meets young (20 years old) Lucy--she lets her sentences become compound and complex, as if all these ideas are suddenly flooding the usually staid Archibald:
He looked down into the girl’s face, and her soft, curved lips made him think of peaches that he had bitten; of grapes that he had tasted; of a cup’s rim from which he had sometimes sipped wine.
Not only is Archibald thinking in metaphor, but in multiple metaphors. So here we see the eventual endpoint of this Easter conversion: Archibald will become a lover of beauty, women, and life--and also probably Christ, though that seems to be downplayed.

But since Chopin never gives us a reason for the conversion; since she keeps us on tenterhooks between Archibald's two states; by the end of the story, I feel a little uncertain as to why we ended up where we did.

Casino Royale, a Structural Review (or review of structure)

I've been rewatching Casino Royale at the gym; and while it's a little long, I think it does some very interesting things structurally to keep the reader's attention and forward the reader's understanding. And I think attention and understanding are very closely aligned, even when the reader/viewer may not be conscious of what that understanding is.

  1. For instance, the movie opens with James Bond earning his 007 status by killing two people: one an Englishman who works for the government--and is betraying that government; and the other a long-haired assistant. Why does this matter?
    • First, it matters because the opening tells us that we're watching an origin story: Casino Royale is the story of how James Bond becomes James Bond. So we open with him earning his 007 status; and we see him bumble his way through a few of the tropes--for instance, saying he doesn't care whether his martini is shaken or stirred; and we finally see him at the end introducing himself with that formula we all know: "I'm Bond--James Bond." So that's a nice parallel between the beginning and end.
    • Second, Bond earns his name by discovering/killing a British traitor and a long-haired associate. So who does Bond take care of during this movie? Vesper Lynd plays a government agent and traitor; and Matthis plays another traitor, this one with the same long hair. That's not a connection the movie stresses; but by playing out a miniature version of the movie in the beginning, the viewer already has a template for what will happen.
  2. The plot is human-level, as Todd Alcott points out, having to do with stock market manipulation and a poker game rather than destroying the world or anything. However, it is still a complicated plot, which is why the film provides many assistants and associates to verbalize certain issues--sometimes in drips of info across the whole movie.
    • Le Chiffre's stockbroker notes that he's betting against the market in shorting the airline stocks; M will later explain to Bond what all that means.
    • For the poker scenes, there is always someone to explain things: the banker Mendel, the dealer, Matthis, Felix Leiter.
    • Note: There are certain issues--like Bond finding M's apartment or hacking into the system with M's password--where there are no answers, which is highlighted by the fact that people wonder about this. M asks at least once "How does he know these things?" This is a great example of "lampshading": by pointing out something that sort of doesn't make sense, the film is preventing us from balking by not believing. 
      • The answer to how James Bond does what he does is always: He's James Bond.
    • Or when Bond searches for information in the MI6 database, M's help often helps us by narrating his search, while M helps by reacting to the information. This isn't just an info-dump, as sometimes this information goes both ways, as when the MI6 organization helps Bond ID the bomb target at the airport or diagnose what he's been poisoned with.
  3. Scenes without action are enlivened by dialogue between characters at odds.
    • Bond and M spar over the dead bomb-maker, M lays out the business--including the exposition that they were looking for more powerful people.
    • Vesper and Bond spar--which also gives them a chance to introduce their characters disguised as a verbal fight.
    • Solange (Dimitrios's wife) pinpoints Bond's character during her seduction: he likes married women because he doesn't want to get attached.
  4. Scenes hook into each other, with almost every scene connected with a "because."
    • For instance, we meet up with Bond while he surveils a bomb-maker. (Again, there's no other explanation for this other than MI6 is surveilling this guy.) He chases the bomb-maker and kills him in an embassy, which makes the front page of newspapers. Because of that...
      • Bond gets the bomber's phone, which will give him a location to search next;
      • Le Chiffre learns the news, realizes he needs a new bomber;
      • and M is very angry because she's just been grilled by the government. (Note: we don't see that government scene because it doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is that M is angry.)
    • Even in little ways, one scene may explain the next. When Le Chiffre's stock option fails, he notes quietly "Someone talked"--and the next scene begins with Solange dead and tortured. (Which also tells us something about Le Chiffre: he tortures people. That will come up later.)
  5. One thing about this screenplay is that it seems to package large sections together. So, for instance, we have a long non-action sequence of how Bond learns about the bombing--then we have the action sequence about that. Then, after that, we have about four scenes of verbal sparring between Bond and M (in the Bahamas); and Bond and Vesper (on the train, in the car to the hotel, at the hotel).
    • This sameness/similarity might be problematic; but each scene of sparring gives us something different. For instance, the train scene shows us these two testing each other; in the car, there's more of a jokey tone between them; but when Bond makes a jerky move at the hotel (abandoning the cover), Vesper is angry. So we get a rollercoaster of their relationship instead of a change in the action.
  6. By contrast, the poker game is kept interesting by making the stakes clear (terrorism) and by intercutting between it and between some other action: the warlord attacks, Vesper is shocked in the shower, bodies are discovered in a car trunk, Bond loses his cool, Bond is poisoned, etc.
  7. Some people might feel that the multiple-endings of the movie is a flaw: first Bond beats Le Chiffre at poker; then Le Chiffre dies at White's hand; then Vesper's betrayal is discovered; then Bond shoots Mr. White. However, we should note that the first villain we actually see is Mr. White; and he shows up again at the end walking away with the money while Bond mourns Vesper. So there is something kind of repetitive about this ending, but again, the opening has helped set up some of it.

Sunday, August 11, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 110: Abraham Lincoln, Remarkable Case of Arrest for Murder (#60)

Abraham Lincoln, "Remarkable Case of Arrest for Murder" (1846) from True Crime: An American Anthology:

Since my usual procedure when reading LoA stories is to read the story first and then the webpage that discusses it, I had a fun time with this one: while reading this, I assumed it was included in a volume of Lincoln's works, and I thought to myself, "This really could go into their True Crime volume." Well, whaddaya know, that's exactly where it is.

In fact, when I think of Lincoln's writing, I tend to think of grand oratory with some down-home folksiness. (Not always in the same piece.) But this story is very prosaic, where Lincoln just lays out--as well as he can--the confusing facts in this case of (not really) murder.

As a fan of John Ford's Young Mr. Lincoln, I half expected this story to be about a murder case involving a farmer's almanac. But it's actually the story of a non-murder, where not all the facts line up neatly. Here's the case: Two Trailor brothers get arrested for murder after the third Trailor provides witness against them. But even though there's lots of circumstantial physical evidence proving third Trailor's story, it eventually turns out that... there never was any murder at all. So Lincoln wraps up with a worry: imagine how wrong the court could have been if the "murder victim" didn't show up.

Yet even with that forward-thinking bit of legal worry, the overwhelming tone here is one of objective fact-giving, like a lot of true crime articles. Which probably means that this is mostly for those true crime fans out there.

Saturday, August 10, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 109: Ida M. Tarbell, Flying—A Dream Come True! (#179)

Ida M. Tarbell, "Flying—A Dream Come True!" (1913) from Into the Blue: American Writers on Aviation and Spaceflight:

When I think of Ida Tarbell, I think of a crusading muckraker and journalist, an anti-monopolist who skewered Standard Oil. I don't think of an aeronautical enthusiast who experienced and wrote about her early flights as a way of popularizing and domesticating this new technology.

But that's the way she comes off here. Unlike the reports of death we get from J. Herman Banning or the reports of uncomfortable commercial air travel we get from Elizabeth Bisgood, the primary note in Tarbell's account is almost ordinariness. While she notes that the "dainty little" plane had "a terrific force in her" (note the feminine in both "dainty" and "her"); and that she felt a sense of exhilaration and "a curious sense of being part of the whole thing [Earth]"; Tarbell ends her account by noting "As a matter of fact, this trip of mine, to those who are familiar with aviation, is the most commonplace kind of thing, not worth a long letter like this."

Which is one of those great sentences that undoes what it says it's doing: my flight isn't worth a long letter--and yet, here's a long letter. There's a curious push and pull to this sort of writing that reminds me of Robert Heinlein's Saturday Morning Post stories: an attempt to write about something that seems both exciting--so that people want to do it--but also safe--so that people aren't afraid to do it. Heinlein wrote about the colonization of the solar system, but it seems to be the same thing that Tarbell is doing here about aviation when she writes both that "that it all was so natural, [...] so easy" and also "so supremely superior to any other motion that I had ever experienced."


Friday, August 9, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 108: Ernie Pyle, “This One Is Captain Waskow” (#74)

Ernie Pyle, “This One Is Captain Waskow” (1944) from Reporting World War II: American Journalism 1938–1944:

Ernie Pyle's report of Captain Waskow's death is very moving because it's so carefully crafted and so cannily underwritten. That is, as a wire story, Pyle doesn't lard his writing with, well, lard: there's no fatty description about the air and the night sky and the Italian landscape.

Instead Pyle starts by focusing on people's feelings about Capt. Waskow: the first section of this piece tells us that Waskow is loved and provides a few quotes to support that claim.

Only after we've established Waskow's essential good-guyness do we switch to the second section, about how the American troops brought down the dead bodies. (And OK, here's a not very useful description of the full moon--but it's just one sentence.) Before we get to Waskow's body, we hear about this somewhat pathetic parade, with dead bodies tied to mules, their rigor mortis-locked legs bouncing in time to the mules.

Only after we've got (a) Waskow was good and (b) here are some dead bodies, do we get the synthesis of this: "This one is Captain Waskow," says one of the men. And after that, since it's too late to help him, the soldiers who liked their comrade say a few final things over his body--mostly things like "Damn it" and "Sorry." Here's where the simpleness of the responses is mirrored by the prose, which again, doesn't overwrite and empurple anything. It is a very effective way that Pyle uses to get out of the way of his own topic; while at the same time, he lets his structure guide the reader.


Short Story Read-Aloud, Week 22

Clarkesworld 

Kij Johnson, "Mantis Wives": A catalog of how female mantises kill their mates, since that's necessary to the procreation process. Horrifying, but not entirely moving. A Hugo nominee this year.

Aliette de Bodard, "Immersion": A story about a technology that allows cultural assimilation. A serious piece that might warrant rereading. Another Hugo nominee.

Drabblecast

Tom Godwin, "Cold Equations": A classic story of a young woman who has to die because she doesn't understand physics. That's one way to look at it. It is a classic and in some ways a very beautiful story; there's something terribly right about the fact that it's a problem story ("How will we slow down the ship AND save the girl?") without a solution.

Escape Artists (Escape Pod, Podcastle, Pseudopod) 

David D. Levine, "The Tale of the Golden Eagle": Reminiscent of Cordwainer Smith, a robot--that was once the brain of a ship--that was once a golden eagle--finds a new owner in a romantic but debt-ridden schemer. Some nice parts.

Katherine Mankiller, "Saving Alan Idle": A genius, wheelchair-bound computer scientist creates an AI--"Alan"--who helps her when some disaster strikes. Not entirely successful, primarily because the AI really just comes off as another person; and the other instances of this AI act differently without any discussion as to why these same "people" act differently.

Merrie Haskell, "Zebulon Vance Sings the Alphabet Songs of Love": A robot actress tired of playing Ophelia meets an ex-child star who helps her grow as a person and artist. Some good ideas, but not necessarily moving.

Alex Wilson, "Vestigial Girl": A smart but physically undeveloped child (genetically engineered from her two dads) believes there's a monster inside her that keeps her from developing, schemes to kill it. Interesting in parts, though I'm pretty averse to brilliant child stories.

Lucy Snyder, "Magdala Amygdala": A sort of take on zombie/vampire myths, with a virus that transforms people and a system in place so that they get some of what they need--brains or blood. (If they have good insurance.) There's a quick shift at the end to some religious cosmicism that doesn't seem to fit.

Ken Liu, "Mono No Aware": (A Japanese title referring to the impermanence of things.) A story of a starship leaving earth before an extinction-level asteroid. Flips back-and-forth between life before the asteroid and life on the ship (where our narrator is the last Japanese person) including a moment of crisis on the ship. It's like a triumphant "Cold Equations," where the narrator sacrifices himself, but notes that everyone is a hero in their own way to lead him to this moment.

Cast of Wonders (Protecting Project Pulp, Tales to Terrify, Starship Sofa)

Gareth Stack, “Herbert Bowman Lay Absolutely Still”: Detective hired by decadent churchman; that's all I remember by the end, though some of the writing at the beginning was interesting.

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 107: Arthur James Lyon Fremantle, Battle of Gettysburg (#182)

Arthur James Lyon Fremantle, "Battle of Gettysburg" (1864) from The Civil War: The Third Year Told by Those Who Lived It:

Furthering my theory that everything today has some precedent in the 19th century, today we have a British writer who is basically embedded with the Confederate Army, reporting from the field. Fremantle was a British military man who took a six month leave to spend time reporting from the American Civil War. Curiously, his book, Three Months in the Southern States: April–June 1863, was printed in London, New York, and Mobile. So I guess everyone was interested in what the war looked like from that POV.

What it looks like is your typical mix: the straight facts of war reportage (what units moved where, who was wounded); character studies (this captain inspired the men by doing this, that guy was indefatigable, this one was loved by his men--much like in tomorrow's entry); and absolutely no mention of what this war is all about: slavery.

In fact, Fremantle's report hits all the right notes of Southern gallantry and bravery in this section, sounding very much like a founding document of the Lost Cause school of history. But let's look at his book. I was curious if it dealt with slavery; and here's the first paragraph (with some emphasis by me):
At the outbreak of the American war, in common with many of my countrymen, I felt very indifferent as to which side might win; but if I had any bias, my sympathies were rather in favor of the North, on account of the dislike which an Englishman naturally feels at the idea of slavery. But soon a sentiment of great admiration for the gallantry and determination of the Southerners, together with the unhappy contrast afforded by the foolish bullying conduct of the Northerners, caused a complete revulsion in my feelings, and I was unable to repress a strong wish to go to America and see something of this wonderful struggle.
If you ever read political reporting today, you'll find a corollary (once again, proving my thesis re: the 19th century and today): people will write "I agree with X politically, but he uses mean words." As if it's more important for some people to be dressed well than it is for all people to be free from slavery.

(If you're curious, "slave" and "slavery" come up about 35 times in this book, including many mentions of how slavery is bad, but the Southerners are familiar and kind to their slaves. Hrm.)

As usual, it's interesting to read something from someone embedded in history who doesn't know how things will turn out. Fremantle ends his book noting that the South is not in such bad shape; and he opens it with the opinion that the Confederacy is bound for greatness. Even his account of Gettysburg ends with the Confederates having had a bad day and needing to move for logistic reasons (ammunition), rather than reporting Gettysburg as a defeat. (To be fair, it was a bad battle for everyone involved.)

Lastly, from a craft perspective, the more prose pieces I read reporting the facts of war--what the land was like, how far a unit had to move to engage the enemy, who was positioned where and when--the more I'm glad for historical military maps. Prose is a good medium for describing how Lee rallied the troops; it's not as good as a map for showing movements over space.

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 106: Judith W. McGuire, “Our Beleaguered City” (#130)

Judith W. McGuire, “Our Beleaguered City” (1862/1867/1889) from The Civil War: The Second Year Told by Those Who Lived It:

Note on the weird dates: 1862 was when McGuire wrote her diary; 1867 was when it was first published; but this text is taken from the 1889 edition.

"Our Beleaguered City" tells the story of a few days in the battle outside Richmond from the POV of someone not directly engaged in the fighting itself. (McGuire was a nurse.) Now most of the piece is given over to recording the events of the battle, which is interesting: without a front-line presence--or Twitter--we can imagine that McGuire is getting most of her information by gossip and the observation of others. This seems very odd to me; I mean, the end of Google Reader was big news where I live, so it's not always easy to put myself in the mindset of someone getting info in this way.

Now, there is another source of observation for the Richmonders, which is direct observation--from a distance--of the battle going on just outside. McGuire notes that lots of people took up posts on top of buildings to watch the battle, which was
a scene of unsurpassed magnificence. The brilliant light of bombs bursting in the air and passing to the ground, the innumerable lesser lights, emitted by thousands and thousands of muskets, together with the roar of artillery and the rattling of small-arms, constituted a scene terrifically grand and imposing.
That's also hard for me to really imagine: what would it be like to be so close to the front-line that you can observe the battle, but far enough away that it takes on an aesthetic sublimity?

There's one final part of the diary that reminds me of how different McGuire's mindset is from my own. After she notes that the Richmonders were watching, she asks
What spell has bound our people? Is their trust in God, and in the valour of our troops, so great that they are unmoved by these terrible demonstrations of our powerful foe? It would seem so, for when the battle was over the crowd dispersed and retired to their respective homes...
There's other ways to describe the Richmonders who stayed to watch the battle, not all of them positive. Yet, in 1862, from the Southron perspective of McGuire, that's all she offers.

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 105: James Fenimore Cooper, Storm and Shipwreck (#187)

James Fenimore Cooper, "Storm and Shipwreck" (1843) from The War of 1812: Writings from America’s Second War of Independence:

Today's selection is a very simple anecdote: during the War of 1812, Ned Myers was on the USS Scourge, patrolling Lake Ontario; the ship sunk in a storm on August 8 (oh, timely), and only a few men survived. Now, that plot is very simple, but I'm a sucker for anything about the War of 1812 or about the culture of the Great Lakes or about Cooper's interest in sea stories. I'm also a sucker for the jargon of people who know what they're talking about; when Myers tells us something about a becket and how Myers sculled, I'm not entirely sure what he's talking about, but it sure sounds like he does. (Seriously, though, I hope this piece comes with a glossary in the book.)

There's one or two interesting moments, as when Ned rescues another sailor, who notes
"Davy has made a good haul, and he gave us a close shave; but he didn’t get you and me.” In this manner did this thoughtless sailor express himself, as soon as rescued from the grasp of death!
But most of the interest of this piece is generated by its history. I don't just mean "as history"--I mean the history of the piece itself, which is a little more complex than the simple plot of the piece. Apparently Ned Myers and J. F. Cooper were friends on their first sailing voyage; and after their lives took them in different directions, Myers contacted Cooper, which re-started the friendship.

Then, to top it all off, the wrecks of the ships from that night were discovered and explored recently.

Monday, August 5, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 104: Charles W. Chesnutt, The Bouquet (#3)

Charles W. Chesnutt, "The Bouquet" (1889) from Charles W. Chesnutt: Stories, Novels, and Essays:

Read one way, Charles Chesnutt's "The Bouquet" is a sentimental story about a poor (black) girl who wants to put a bouquet of flowers on her dead (white) teacher's grave. There's a sentimental obstacle--the mother of the dead teacher doesn't want black people at the funeral--and there's the super-sentimental helper--the dead teacher's white-as-wool dog, who has a playful rivalry for the affection of the teacher, but who turns up to help the little girl just in time. Simple, sentimental, heart-warming.

But seriously, this is the sort of story that makes me want to go back to school and write papers. First, it's easy to dislike the racist mother who doesn't want her daughter to teach at the black school, even though the family needs more income post-Civil War. As dear old mom puts it, “It’s a long step from owning such people to teaching them."

But the daughter isn't exactly a peach herself. I mean, you could read this and come away with the idea that the daughter, while not exactly progressive, adapted more easily to the new racial tolerance. And then we get this sentence, about the attention/adoration she got from that one girl who worships her:
[W]hen she grew more accustomed to it, she found it rather to her liking. It had a sort of flavor of the old régime, and she felt, when she bestowed her kindly notice upon her little black attendant, some of the feudal condescension of the mistress toward the slave.
What the what?

Take that along with the steady equation of "little black girl who adores the teacher" and "little white dog who adores the teacher" and we have a sentimental story that's a little thornier than your average "innocent loves attentive and dead teacher." So when the happy end is "girl is kept out of white cemetery, but little white dog helps deliver funeral bouquet, and then resumes position at the grave, while little girl envies the dog," that's the sort of "happy ending" where I think we can feel less than thrilled.

There's a lot more to say about Chesnutt's story, but I want to end with a craft issue, which is that so much of this story is told in summary, not dramatic scenes. But it's still something of a shock when we read the teacher's death summarized like this:
The children made rapid progress under her tuition, and learned to love her well; for they saw and appreciated, as well as children could, her fidelity to a trust that she might have slighted, as some others did, without much fear of criticism. Toward the end of her second year she sickened, and after a brief illness died.
Here's a character who, for the first few pages, might have been taken as the protagonist: she's the first character mentioned, she's potentially risking some social censure by teaching at the black school, she's defying the wishes of her mother, etc. You might have thought she was the heroine here--until her death is taken care of in one line that occurs right after a totally different, much longer line, focused on the children she teaches. So if mean old mom is racist and young daughter is less racist, we might want to look at these children as being the better hope for our future: they are our heroes.

Crisis and Character: Do characters have to change?

Well, that's a bad way to phrase the question: Do characters have to change? No. Thanks for coming, see you next week, and tip your waitress.

Maybe ask it this way: Do readers/viewers respond more when the character faces some crisis and changes? That's a little more complex a question and I'd like to look at two action/adventure films that I genuinely like and see what role character growth plays in my enjoyment. It helps that both films feature big guys punching Nazis.

Hellboy
Hellboy is an interesting film in that it flirts for a while with multiple protagonists: Hellboy seemingly has to face up to his freakish nature and human choices, while Agent Myers seemingly has to deal with the strangeness of the world. I say "seemingly" because both of these plot lines are really quickly handled or not really addressed. Hellboy starts off as a big lug whose solution to things is to hit them very hard; he ends up as the same. Myers may start off as the naive viewpoint character, but after one "what is that thing?" and one "I don't belong here," we never hear a peep about that.

Even Hellboy's major crisis moment is pretty weak sauce; when the movie presents the question "will he or won't he help Rasputin call down the Ogdru-Jahad?," not only is the answer an obvious "NO," but that answer remains pretty solid throughout the movie. There's one brief moment where Hellboy helps Rasputin and we see some cool special effects about what that means--and good thing too, because otherwise we might wonder why Hellboy is suddenly helping the guy who killed his dad and his love interest.

In fact, if we wanted characters who seem to change, we'd have to look to the director of the Bureau (played by Jeffrey Tambor) and to Liz Sherman. The director starts out as a bureaucrat/spokesperson; he ends as a field agent. He begins with a distrust of Hellboy as just another freak; and he ends working with Hellboy to kill a supernatural Nazi and then teaching him to light a cigar. Can we say here that a cigar isn't just a cigar? It's clear that Tambor's character grows from disapproving to supportive father figure. Why he changes is a little less clear to me; and after that support, he's left behind, another reminder of his symbolic role. (Another reminder: I don't even remember his name.)

Liz Sherman also changes pretty quickly, from person who doesn't trust her powers and thinks it would be weird to date Hellboy; to person who uses her out-of-control powers and kisses Hellboy. That first change takes a while and is fairly played out, with Myers (and Abe Sapien) building up a trusting relationship. The second is a little quicker and stranger, seeming to be based on the "you'd do that for me" moment of Hellboy killing monsters for Liz. (Of course, he'd do that anyway.)

So while Hellboy doesn't really change all that much, the movie presents an illusion of character growth by having the characters around him consider him differently.

Captain America
I did say I was going to look at two movies about big guys hitting Nazis and whether the main characters actually grow at all. With Captain America, the case seems easier: (a) there's no one else to compete for screen time with him the way Myers competes with Hellboy; (b) he undergoes some serious physical change.

But that physical change that makes Steve Rogers into Captain America only brings out the heroic qualities that were in Steve to begin with. And the movie does this brilliantly, setting up his inner heroism in a bunch of smaller scenes that make his later heroism believable as part of his character. In other words, at the end of the movie, Rogers chooses to sacrifice himself to save New York; and we know he would do the exact same thing at the beginning since we've seen it in much smaller ways--like when he sacrificed himself to fight a bully so that other people could enjoy the movie and honor the troops in the newsreel. In other words, there's no internal conflict, no crisis of character for Captain America to face. He starts off as a boy scout and he ends up as a boy scout.

There is one way that he does change, though: as the movie goes on, he gets better at talking to girls. Specifically, he gets better at talking to Peggy Carter. When we first see Rogers with girls (at the World's Fair), he has no interest in women; later, Carter even calls him out on his awkwardness when she takes him to the experiment; but by the end of the movie, after they have the requisite "this isn't what it looks like" misunderstanding, he's flirting right back with her. That's something he couldn't have done before.

And again, while the core of Steve Rogers doesn't change, we get some illusion of change through the fact that other people look at him differently. In fact, it's the Colonel (played by Tommy Lee Jones) and Peggy Carter that seem to look at him differently--and they occupy the same positions as the characters in Hellboy: the boss and the love interest.

The villains' story
Here's another interesting parallel between Hellboy and Captain America: both start with a tiny prologue introducing the main character--but not really: we see Hellboy as a baby and Captain America as a popsicle. (Actually, we don't see him frozen, but we see his shield). And then both movies introduce us to the villains, whether Rasputin reborn or Red Skull finding his cube.

This early focus on the villains might threaten to make them the center of our attention, except (a) they're both marked as EVIL; and (b) despite some cool character design, these guys never really become interesting. Rasputin wants to summon dark gods and Red Skull wants to control the world. Why? No reason--or backstory--is given. What interesting positive traits do they have? Well, Rasputin loves his she-wolf, Ilsa; and Red Skull is clever enough to find the cube. But there's nothing really surprising--no, "Rasputin loves puppies" or anything like that.

Conclusion
Character change is often considered a requirement of good story-telling; but at the same time, in action/adventure movies, we often like our protagonists to start off as good guys. So the change in these two movies isn't in the essential goodness of the characters, but in some other quality--or sometimes just in the illusion that change is taking place by having supporting characters change their opinions.

Sunday, August 4, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 103: Waverly Root, The Flying Fool (#34)

Waverly Root, "The Flying Fool" (1987) from Americans in Paris: A Literary Anthology:

This piece appeared after Root's death, if I'm reading the dates right; which has no bearing on my topic other than to note that it appeared long after Lindbergh's solo flight from New York to Paris. So Root gets to give us the long view, both about what Lindbergh's flight meant and what people thought at the time. And most importantly, how big a gap there was.

That's kind of the major motif of this gently funny piece: everyone was caught by surprise by Lindbergh's flight. The newspaper editors didn't think he would make it; the politicians were caught by surprise; the police under-reacted by sending hardly any cops to deal with the crowd of well-wishers; etc.

In fact, it's about eight pages of gently poking fun at all the people who either misunderstood Lindbergh or tried to turn his triumph to their own ends; and then we get two pages of how Lindbergh totally knew what he was doing. Lindbergh didn't take a radio or a co-pilot because he totally knew he could do it. If you wrote that section today, you'd say, "we can't call him 'Lucky Lindy' because he's just that hardcore."

Saturday, August 3, 2013

Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 102: Ellen Glasgow, The Shadowy Third (#101)

Ellen Glasgow, "The Shadowy Third" (1916) from American Fantastic Tales: Terror and the Uncanny from Poe to the Pulps:

I've never read Ellen Glasgow before, so I just have to take on faith that the LoA page is correct in its comments on how her short fiction shows her transition from some kind of fiction to some other kind. I can more securely discuss the description of this ghost story as Jamesian as both totally right (it's a genteel story about a child haunting that might be real (but yeah, totally is)); and also as giving James a little too much credit in the psychological supernatural field. James merely gave us, in "Turn of the Screw," one of the best versions--and the one most often read by people in college. (It's an example of Google selection bias before Google: the more people read that story, the more likely it is to get mentioned/linked, the more people then go on to read it.)

But "Shadowy Third" probably also reminds people of James in the Wings of the Dove background: doctor marries rich woman so that he can marry his true love after he inherits all her money. It is also, like James, told with a certain amount of uncertainty and ambiguity: although the nurse narrator totally did see the ghost child, she still can't give definitive answers about what happened or what motivated the people in the story. People are as shadowy and unknowable as ghosts here. So when the narrator sums up the doctor/killer with "He was, I suppose, born to be a hero to women," we should pay attention not just to her worshipful judgment, but that "I suppose" that interrupts the sentence.

Which is probably why this isn't just a story about violence against women or ghostly revenge, but about the special ability to know and how knowledge may change one. For instance, there's lots of precise description about who is wearing what or what the garden looks like. And then we get the description of the ghost child's eyes:
For the odd thing about this look was that it was not the look of childhood at all. It was the look of profound experience, of bitter knowledge.
Oh god, how many times are you going to say "look"? If I wrote that, it would be bad style; but Glasgow focuses on the look--the look the girl gives her, the fact that the nurse can look at the child, the understanding of "look" as something more abstract than "eyes." 

We see this throughout the piece, where the imaginative and sympathetic nurse gains some extra knowledge--she's the only one who can see the child-ghost besides the mother. Why? Because she's imaginative and sympathetic--a novelist manque. So she gets special information, but doesn't know how: "How the warning reached me--what invisible waves of sense perception transmitted the message--I have never known."

But there's also something special about the narrator that isn't peculiar to her, but to her profession. As her boss (and distant relative) notes, nurses get hardened by what they see and learn--just like child-ghosts. And sometimes that means that the narrator can't really fully describe what's going on, but bases her observations on some shared knowledge: "He was the sort of physician--every nurse will understand what I mean--who deals instinctively with groups instead of with individuals." That the nurse's observation about a type of doctor is directed towards a group of nurses is the sort of reflexive and ambiguous comment that keeps this from being a scary ghost story, and more a meditation on knowable-ness and tellable-ness. Like a James story.