Katherine Anne Porter, "The Charmed Life" (1942/1952) from Katherine Anne Porter: Collected Stories and Other Writings:
"The Charmed Life" is a portrait of "the Old Man," a freelance archaeologist who lives in Mexico and sells what he digs up. He's by turns described as authentic; eccentric; living an uncomplicated and whole life; completely free of family; and having a family who lives in America and visits him every few years to make sure he is doing ok. So, yeah, in five short pages the narrator of this piece gets one "sentimental" view of the Old Man and then learns what fits and doesn't. Curiously, by the end, though he has morphed from "Old Man" to "Wild Man," the final pronouncement is that he lived a charmed life and was impervious to danger.
Curiously, this character sketch is actually based on a real person, the eccentric archaeologist William Niven. Which makes the story a little crazier as a historical piece. Wait, did he really have a collection of letters that would prove to be political dynamite?
Otherwise, the abstracted and nutty professor portrait reminds me most of Willa Cather's portrait of Stephen Crane. Nice to see that this treatment isn't restricted to artists.
Friday, August 2, 2013
Short Story Read-Aloud, Week 21
Drabblecast
David Barr Kirtley, "Power Armor: A Love Story": A cute story that is on the border of overly metaphorical: a man from the future won't take off his power armor because he's afraid of assassins from the future. So when he falls in love with an assassin, will he take off his armor and let her in?
Escape Artists (Escape Pod, Podcastle, Pseudopod)
Ferrett Steinmetz, "Riding Atlas": A nebbishy guy is afraid of losing his girlfriend, so agrees to do this blood-sharing weekend that is supposed to be mind-expanding. It is. The end. Fine characterization and the hints of Lovecraftian cosmic horror are fun, but the story is very thin.
Lightspeed and Nightmare
Cherie Priest, "Addison Howell and the Clockroach": A curious three-part story, with (1) an oral history from a woman whose town experienced something weird; (2) a researcher commenting on the story; and (3) a museum's exhibit notes. I liked the first two parts, which rub up against each other interestingly (how things are remembered vs. the few facts we have about the real history); but am not sure why the third part is included.
Carrie Vaughn, "Fishwife": Told from a slight distance--we get it all over the shoulder of a fisherman's wife, but without dialogue or names, like a bird's eye limited third--this story is like "The Shadow over Innsmouth" told from the POV of the poor villagers who have a choice: starve in poverty or start worshipping and sacrificing strangers to the sea god? Although it's told in this distanced style, it also delves deeply into the emotions and thoughts of this woman, which helps to make it affecting.
Cast of Wonders (Protecting Project Pulp, Tales to Terrify, Starship Sofa)
Margo Lanagan, "The Goosle": A rewriting of Hansel and Gretel, where Hansel escapes and becomes the companion and rape-victim of a man. Dark and interesting, but ultimately doesn't move me because it doesn't really do much with the Hansel/Gretel frame.
Mark Morris, "What Nature Abhors": Man gets off a deserted train to see a creepy deserted town and discovers a small child yelling for its dad to stop. Creepy end, but very long build-up--too long.
Michael Penkas, "Wet Dog Perfume": A suicidal guy whose dog just died meets a woman who can bring back his ghost for a final reconciliation. There's a hint of open-ended horror at the end, but mostly it seemed sweet.
Felicity Dowker, "Bread and Circuses": A nonsensical premise I had trouble getting around: after the zombies, people build up a civilization in the graveyards (where the zombies don't go), but apparently only dicks survived because they institute a man-vs.-zombie gladiator game.
William Hope Hodgson, “A Voice in the Night”: Man on ship meets other man who tells a story of shipwreck and woe and fungus.
Henry Kuttner, "Raiders of the Spaceways": An excellently paced, thinly characterized story of (a) a man who harvests this miracle drug on Venus and the girl he likes, (b) the space raider who attempts to steal the drug, (c) the fight with another ship to get away, (d) and the monster who attacks them on the nightside of Venus. Each section complicates or raises the stakes for the hero.
Clark Ashton Smith, "Mother of Toads": A witch magics a boy into sleeping with her and when he tries to get away, she kills him with a flood of toads. Ridiculous (especially if you put it into modern parlance where the witch basically roofies the boy), but atmospheric.
David Barr Kirtley, "Power Armor: A Love Story": A cute story that is on the border of overly metaphorical: a man from the future won't take off his power armor because he's afraid of assassins from the future. So when he falls in love with an assassin, will he take off his armor and let her in?
Escape Artists (Escape Pod, Podcastle, Pseudopod)
Ferrett Steinmetz, "Riding Atlas": A nebbishy guy is afraid of losing his girlfriend, so agrees to do this blood-sharing weekend that is supposed to be mind-expanding. It is. The end. Fine characterization and the hints of Lovecraftian cosmic horror are fun, but the story is very thin.
Lightspeed and Nightmare
Cherie Priest, "Addison Howell and the Clockroach": A curious three-part story, with (1) an oral history from a woman whose town experienced something weird; (2) a researcher commenting on the story; and (3) a museum's exhibit notes. I liked the first two parts, which rub up against each other interestingly (how things are remembered vs. the few facts we have about the real history); but am not sure why the third part is included.
Carrie Vaughn, "Fishwife": Told from a slight distance--we get it all over the shoulder of a fisherman's wife, but without dialogue or names, like a bird's eye limited third--this story is like "The Shadow over Innsmouth" told from the POV of the poor villagers who have a choice: starve in poverty or start worshipping and sacrificing strangers to the sea god? Although it's told in this distanced style, it also delves deeply into the emotions and thoughts of this woman, which helps to make it affecting.
Cast of Wonders (Protecting Project Pulp, Tales to Terrify, Starship Sofa)
Margo Lanagan, "The Goosle": A rewriting of Hansel and Gretel, where Hansel escapes and becomes the companion and rape-victim of a man. Dark and interesting, but ultimately doesn't move me because it doesn't really do much with the Hansel/Gretel frame.
Mark Morris, "What Nature Abhors": Man gets off a deserted train to see a creepy deserted town and discovers a small child yelling for its dad to stop. Creepy end, but very long build-up--too long.
Michael Penkas, "Wet Dog Perfume": A suicidal guy whose dog just died meets a woman who can bring back his ghost for a final reconciliation. There's a hint of open-ended horror at the end, but mostly it seemed sweet.
Felicity Dowker, "Bread and Circuses": A nonsensical premise I had trouble getting around: after the zombies, people build up a civilization in the graveyards (where the zombies don't go), but apparently only dicks survived because they institute a man-vs.-zombie gladiator game.
William Hope Hodgson, “A Voice in the Night”: Man on ship meets other man who tells a story of shipwreck and woe and fungus.
Henry Kuttner, "Raiders of the Spaceways": An excellently paced, thinly characterized story of (a) a man who harvests this miracle drug on Venus and the girl he likes, (b) the space raider who attempts to steal the drug, (c) the fight with another ship to get away, (d) and the monster who attacks them on the nightside of Venus. Each section complicates or raises the stakes for the hero.
Clark Ashton Smith, "Mother of Toads": A witch magics a boy into sleeping with her and when he tries to get away, she kills him with a flood of toads. Ridiculous (especially if you put it into modern parlance where the witch basically roofies the boy), but atmospheric.
Thursday, August 1, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 100: Robert Frost, The Question of a Feather (#133)
Robert Frost, "The Question of a Feather" (1903) from Robert Frost: Collected Poems, Prose, & Plays:
Here is the second Robert Frost Story of the Week and again, just like the first piece, it's one of his poultry pieces. This one is less of a character sketch and more of a traditional, New England-style story. By "New England-style," I mean that it's a low-stakes story involving a man going to see some isolated old women, not unlike Sarah Orne Jewett's "An Autumn Holiday."
In this story, the editor of a chicken-instruction magazine gets a letter asking him to stop in and give these two old maids some advice about a chicken they want to exhibit. The only problem is this chicken has got an errant feather. So should they pull the feather? Or not exhibit him? The editor avoids giving an answer; and later, sees that they chose not to pull the feather and exhibit it--and of course it gets disqualified.
It's a pretty thin story, but there's a vein of humor running through it, as when we hear about the editor being afraid that people would take his advice; or how he might just be "shy of old maids disposed to follow his instructions to the letter." There's also a little farce about the confusion between "pullet" and "pull it," but that seems like it wandered in from some other story.
Here is the second Robert Frost Story of the Week and again, just like the first piece, it's one of his poultry pieces. This one is less of a character sketch and more of a traditional, New England-style story. By "New England-style," I mean that it's a low-stakes story involving a man going to see some isolated old women, not unlike Sarah Orne Jewett's "An Autumn Holiday."
In this story, the editor of a chicken-instruction magazine gets a letter asking him to stop in and give these two old maids some advice about a chicken they want to exhibit. The only problem is this chicken has got an errant feather. So should they pull the feather? Or not exhibit him? The editor avoids giving an answer; and later, sees that they chose not to pull the feather and exhibit it--and of course it gets disqualified.
It's a pretty thin story, but there's a vein of humor running through it, as when we hear about the editor being afraid that people would take his advice; or how he might just be "shy of old maids disposed to follow his instructions to the letter." There's also a little farce about the confusion between "pullet" and "pull it," but that seems like it wandered in from some other story.
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 99: Mark Twain, Hunting the Deceitful Turkey (#47)
Mark Twain, "Hunting the Deceitful Turkey" (1906) from Mark Twain: Collected Tales, Sketches, Speeches, & Essays 1891–1910:
A short piece about Twain's childhood experience of hunting, including an epic battle with a turkey who faked injury to lure Twain away from its kids. Although the piece has an obvious holiday appeal around Thanksgiving time; and though there was an important reason for putting this out in the year when his full autobiography was published; I find this story amusing and not much more. There's some nice self-derision about his poor shooting skills; and there's this one incredibly dark moment when Twain notes that the best turkey call is created from a turkey leg bone--
A short piece about Twain's childhood experience of hunting, including an epic battle with a turkey who faked injury to lure Twain away from its kids. Although the piece has an obvious holiday appeal around Thanksgiving time; and though there was an important reason for putting this out in the year when his full autobiography was published; I find this story amusing and not much more. There's some nice self-derision about his poor shooting skills; and there's this one incredibly dark moment when Twain notes that the best turkey call is created from a turkey leg bone--
There is nothing that furnishes a perfect turkey-call except that bone. Another of Nature's treacheries, you see. She is full of them; half the time she doesn't know which she likes best--to betray her chid or protect it.But besides that it's just hyperbole and understatement--his two classic comic modes--about hunting a turkey.
Tuesday, July 30, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 98: Mary Church Terrell, What It Means to be Colored in the Capital of the United States (#55)
Mary Church Terrell, "What It Means to be Colored in the Capital of the United States" (1907) from American Speeches: Political Oratory from Abraham Lincoln to Bill Clinton:
One of my favorite moments in Charles Chesnutt's Marrow of Tradition--oh, who am I kidding, the entire book is full of favorite moments. But one part that always cuts me deep is when a black man walks through mob-controlled Wellington and gets stopped by a bunch of white guys who think they're the law now--now and forever, I should say, since mob rule merely puts into effect what was more or less always true, according to these white supremacists. But that's not the part that gets me. (Although, after the Trayvon Martin case, I think we might want to reread Chesnutt and think about the problem he noted over a century ago.) No, the part that gets me is this:
As rhetoric, Terrell hits hard on the phrase "Not long ago," reminding the listener that all of these moments of discrimination are recent (in addition to making no sense and being pointlessly cruel, especially to children whose understanding of race is simultaneous with their understanding of their exile from parks and theaters). It occasionally gets repetitive, but that's part of the rhetorical work here: to show the commonplaceness of this discrimination, which, as Terrell notes, is even more hypocritical in the capital of a country devoted to liberty and equality.
One of my favorite moments in Charles Chesnutt's Marrow of Tradition--oh, who am I kidding, the entire book is full of favorite moments. But one part that always cuts me deep is when a black man walks through mob-controlled Wellington and gets stopped by a bunch of white guys who think they're the law now--now and forever, I should say, since mob rule merely puts into effect what was more or less always true, according to these white supremacists. But that's not the part that gets me. (Although, after the Trayvon Martin case, I think we might want to reread Chesnutt and think about the problem he noted over a century ago.) No, the part that gets me is this:
The man who last stopped him was a well-known Jewish merchant. A Jew—God of Moses!—had so far forgotten twenty centuries of history as to join in the persecution of another oppressed race!And so when I read Mary Church Terrell's speech and pamphlet on the contemporary problems of being black in America in 1907, I wasn't surprised to see an instance of a shop owner firing an excellent employee because she was black and reading
The proprietor of this store was a Jew, and I felt that it was particularly cruel, unnatural and cold blooded for the representative of one oppressed and persecuted race to deal so harshly and unjustly with a member of another.
In fact, since Chesnutt and Terrell are writing about the same issue in almost the same time and place, there's lots of connections and parallels: besides the "even the Jews are no help," there's the "everyone pays attention to race and no one pays attention to class and education" moment; there's the "our money isn't any good here"; there's the "other races get treated fairly"; and, above all, there's the "with so much race-mixing, what does 'black' even mean?"
Actually, I think Terrell might have the best formulation of that last problem, noting that the color line is enforced even against a man "who looks more like his paternal ancestors who fought for the lost cause than his grandmothers who were the victims of the peculiar institution"--which is a nice reminder of the violence against black women tied up with the gentility of southern slavery.
As rhetoric, Terrell hits hard on the phrase "Not long ago," reminding the listener that all of these moments of discrimination are recent (in addition to making no sense and being pointlessly cruel, especially to children whose understanding of race is simultaneous with their understanding of their exile from parks and theaters). It occasionally gets repetitive, but that's part of the rhetorical work here: to show the commonplaceness of this discrimination, which, as Terrell notes, is even more hypocritical in the capital of a country devoted to liberty and equality.
Monday, July 29, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 97: David H. Keller, The Jelly-Fish (#157)
David H. Keller, "The Jelly-Fish" (1929) from American Fantastic Tales: Terror and the Uncanny from Poe to the Pulps:
The LoA page for this story hits a few important points about Keller: he was a doctor, served in WWI, dealt with shell-shock, wrote all his life but only later started to send stories out, and has some reservations about technological optimism. For more on Keller, see the SF Encyclopedia and Fantasy Encyclopedia entries, which has a lot more info on him and (as usual for those publications) some analysis. There's his Charles Atlas physical education non-fiction! There's his occult detective series! There's his weird sexual hang-ups!
All of which makes Keller sound like a fascinating subject to study; but maybe not the most interesting pulp author to reread nowadays. Curiously, both encyclopedia entries mention a few of his works, but neither mention "The Jelly-Fish." Which is no surprise after we read this rather silly story: on a research yacht studying micro-organisms in the ocean, the hated and smug professor gives a speech about how everything is possible with the will and he will demonstrate this by shrinking down to microscopic jelly-fish size--at which point he gets eaten by a jelly-fish. There's really no surprise there and no shock. The story mostly leaves one with the desire to chuckle. The mad scientist is so over-the-top mad, the action is so ridiculous ("by my will I can change into a microscopic version of myself and not worry about, you know, drowning in the drop of water, but I'm helpless when confronted by a jellyfish"?).
That said, we could put this in the long line of microscopic fiction, from Fitz-James O'Brien's brilliant "The Diamond Lens" to Richard Matheson's unrealistic but thematically interesting The Incredible Shrinking Man. And I wonder if you could do something like this today? Or should we leap over the small scale here and just write Jelly-fishnado?
The LoA page for this story hits a few important points about Keller: he was a doctor, served in WWI, dealt with shell-shock, wrote all his life but only later started to send stories out, and has some reservations about technological optimism. For more on Keller, see the SF Encyclopedia and Fantasy Encyclopedia entries, which has a lot more info on him and (as usual for those publications) some analysis. There's his Charles Atlas physical education non-fiction! There's his occult detective series! There's his weird sexual hang-ups!
All of which makes Keller sound like a fascinating subject to study; but maybe not the most interesting pulp author to reread nowadays. Curiously, both encyclopedia entries mention a few of his works, but neither mention "The Jelly-Fish." Which is no surprise after we read this rather silly story: on a research yacht studying micro-organisms in the ocean, the hated and smug professor gives a speech about how everything is possible with the will and he will demonstrate this by shrinking down to microscopic jelly-fish size--at which point he gets eaten by a jelly-fish. There's really no surprise there and no shock. The story mostly leaves one with the desire to chuckle. The mad scientist is so over-the-top mad, the action is so ridiculous ("by my will I can change into a microscopic version of myself and not worry about, you know, drowning in the drop of water, but I'm helpless when confronted by a jellyfish"?).
That said, we could put this in the long line of microscopic fiction, from Fitz-James O'Brien's brilliant "The Diamond Lens" to Richard Matheson's unrealistic but thematically interesting The Incredible Shrinking Man. And I wonder if you could do something like this today? Or should we leap over the small scale here and just write Jelly-fishnado?
The New New Thing: Paolo Bacigalupi, "Pop Squad"; "Yellow Card Man"; "Softer"; "Pump Six"; "Small Offerings"
I finally finished Paolo Bacigalupi's Pump Six and Other Stories; so this omnibus post will cover the final five stories and any general comments I want to make. I previously posted on Pump Six stories here, here, here, here, and here.
The last five stories I'll cover today are
The last five stories I'll cover today are
- "Pop Squad" (2006): in a future where humans are functionally immortal and procreation is illegal, some people go off their immortality meds so they can have kids; our protagonist is one of the cops whose job it is to track down these women and kill the kids. Bonus: people seem to live in a jungle that was once the tundra, complete now with lots monkeys.
- "Yellow Card Man" (2006): once a rich man in Malaysia, the protagonist was forced out by nationalist riots and now tries to survive as one of the yellow card men (refugee immigrants), avoiding the white uniformed Environment Ministry cops/thugs. This takes place in the Wind-Up Girl universe; and is a novella in length.
- "Softer" (2007): a man kills his wife, thinks his life is over, but when he gets away it, decides to rededicate himself to really living his life. The only non-science fiction story in the collection.
- "Pump Six" (2008): reminiscent of The Marching Morons and Idiocracy, an average man tries to save the city of idiots by keeping the sewage system working. Bonus: the man and his wife are trying to have a baby, hoping the environmental pollutants don't give them an idiot; and the city is overrun with these monkey-like idiot hominids.
- "Small Offerings" (2007): in a polluted world, a doctor wants to leach the pollutants from her body to have a normal baby, which is a better alternative to having a dead baby just to clear the pollutants for a good baby.
All the other stories share a real interest in environmental/ecological issues, including pollutants. Whereas the protagonists of "The People of Sand and Slag" were physically impervious, normal humans in these stories tend to be undone by their environments. (Or by their parents' environments in the case of the idiot kids and troglodytes of "Pump Six.")
"Pop Squad" might be a slight outlier here, since what people are undone by are their own inbuilt urges to have kids. Although they are living in a post-climate change world, the problem isn't that; the problem is that they have two genetic imperatives warring: the desire to live and the desire to pass on one's genes. The environmental issues seems secondary.
"Yellow Card Man," "Pump Six," and "Small Offerings" all tell the story of someone fighting the environment, whether that environment includes dangerous people; idiots and pollutants; or pollutants.
OK, fine, I told you what they're about; but how good are they? "Yellow Card Man" is clearly the standout here, not as a story--it's an almost structureless meander through the life and incidents of an old man--but as a world that he's building. It's hard to say since I've already read another Wind-Up story and know that was the world for his novel; but that world seems the richest and most interesting.
Sunday, July 28, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 96: Herman Melville, The Fiddler (#141)
Herman Melville, "The Fiddler" (1854) from Herman Melville: Pierre, Israel Potter, The Piazza Tales, The Confidence-Man, Billy Budd, & Uncollected Prose:
If Twitter had existed in the 1890s, the general response to news of Herman Melville's 1891 death would have been "He was still alive? I thought he died years ago." Honestly, I studied 19th-century literature and I'm still surprised he died in the 90s since so much of his famous work was in the 40s and 50s. And I say this as someone whose favorite Melville novel might be his last: The Confidence-Man, 1857.
But though Melville dropped off the list of famous authors, his career sealed by poor sales and negative reviews (like the 1852 review titled "Herman Melville Crazy"), he did keep writing and even got a few short pieces published in the big-name magazines. Which brings us to "The Fiddler," a short piece claimed to be by Melville in his wife's memoranda; and which seems to deal with some of the issues he was dealing with in real life. To wit: "The Fiddler" starts with a poet who has gotten bad reviews and follows him as he sees popular but dumb entertainment--the clown at the circus; and genius but obscure entertainment--the fiddler who was once famous but is now happy just giving fiddling lessons and playing common songs.
So... yeah. Unlike many of my favorite Melville pieces, this doesn't quite reach the heights of weirdness of, say, "The Paradise of Bachelors and the Tartarus of Maids" or "Bartleby" or even "I and My Chimney." It has the balance--or ambivalence--that we can find in lots of Melville: we may both feel bad for and despise the egotistic poet at the beginning; and we might pity and celebrate his final choice to pick up the fiddle instead of the poem. (We might as well ask why he doesn't pick up the clown makeup, since the story seems to indicate some happiness even there.)
But at the end of the day, this doesn't leave a very strong impression since it lacks Melville's humor and wordplay.
If Twitter had existed in the 1890s, the general response to news of Herman Melville's 1891 death would have been "He was still alive? I thought he died years ago." Honestly, I studied 19th-century literature and I'm still surprised he died in the 90s since so much of his famous work was in the 40s and 50s. And I say this as someone whose favorite Melville novel might be his last: The Confidence-Man, 1857.
But though Melville dropped off the list of famous authors, his career sealed by poor sales and negative reviews (like the 1852 review titled "Herman Melville Crazy"), he did keep writing and even got a few short pieces published in the big-name magazines. Which brings us to "The Fiddler," a short piece claimed to be by Melville in his wife's memoranda; and which seems to deal with some of the issues he was dealing with in real life. To wit: "The Fiddler" starts with a poet who has gotten bad reviews and follows him as he sees popular but dumb entertainment--the clown at the circus; and genius but obscure entertainment--the fiddler who was once famous but is now happy just giving fiddling lessons and playing common songs.
So... yeah. Unlike many of my favorite Melville pieces, this doesn't quite reach the heights of weirdness of, say, "The Paradise of Bachelors and the Tartarus of Maids" or "Bartleby" or even "I and My Chimney." It has the balance--or ambivalence--that we can find in lots of Melville: we may both feel bad for and despise the egotistic poet at the beginning; and we might pity and celebrate his final choice to pick up the fiddle instead of the poem. (We might as well ask why he doesn't pick up the clown makeup, since the story seems to indicate some happiness even there.)
But at the end of the day, this doesn't leave a very strong impression since it lacks Melville's humor and wordplay.
Saturday, July 27, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 95: Harvey Shapiro, War Stories (#177)
Harvey Shapiro, "War Stories" (1966) from Poets of World War II:
"War Stories" does double-duty, both as a poem and as a reason to explain why the LoA put out Poets of World War II: in the intro, editor Harvey Shapiro explained that he wanted to counter the idea that World War I was singular in its poetic output. (Also, the LoA page notes that this volume was a commercial success, with 18,000 in print, which makes me enormously sad.)
As a poem, "War Stories" is both different from and similar to Edward Fields's war poem from the same volume: there's the same tone through much of the poem, presenting just the facts in straightforward sentences. But rather than step-by-step recounting of just another crazy incident of war, Shapiro jumps around in time, telling about three-four incidents in his life--training, R&R, going on a mission--all revolving in some way about media and the stories we tell.
In the first part, Shapiro talks about his childhood of comic strips and radio serials, Popeye and Buck Rogers fighting for right; and after an interlude of re-use in pornography, they come back as marching songs during his training. So there's childish stories we tell (contrasted with his dad's political beliefs, the fact that he doesn't get Hearst papers except for Sunday's edition, for the comics) and there's the re-use/reality.
In the second part, we again get that theme of story-telling vs. reality: in an Italian bar, a Brit tells Shapiro that the Italians are a conquered people, which sure sounds great and historical but doesn't actually match what Shapiro sees on the ground. So when Shapiro notes "I was part of that sergeant’s fictive world," we should read it both ways: "I was part" but that world is "fictive."
In the final part, Shapiro is on a mission to bomb Germany; and unlike the other sections, where Shapiro pulls together multiple images or stories, this section is purely given over to the repeated experience of the bombing run. Which culminates in the final (and only for this section) mention of media:
Bonus: What's up with Shapiro's "little friend, little friend" interjection? Is it a reference to Randall Jarrell's 1945 book of poetry of that name?
"War Stories" does double-duty, both as a poem and as a reason to explain why the LoA put out Poets of World War II: in the intro, editor Harvey Shapiro explained that he wanted to counter the idea that World War I was singular in its poetic output. (Also, the LoA page notes that this volume was a commercial success, with 18,000 in print, which makes me enormously sad.)
As a poem, "War Stories" is both different from and similar to Edward Fields's war poem from the same volume: there's the same tone through much of the poem, presenting just the facts in straightforward sentences. But rather than step-by-step recounting of just another crazy incident of war, Shapiro jumps around in time, telling about three-four incidents in his life--training, R&R, going on a mission--all revolving in some way about media and the stories we tell.
In the first part, Shapiro talks about his childhood of comic strips and radio serials, Popeye and Buck Rogers fighting for right; and after an interlude of re-use in pornography, they come back as marching songs during his training. So there's childish stories we tell (contrasted with his dad's political beliefs, the fact that he doesn't get Hearst papers except for Sunday's edition, for the comics) and there's the re-use/reality.
In the second part, we again get that theme of story-telling vs. reality: in an Italian bar, a Brit tells Shapiro that the Italians are a conquered people, which sure sounds great and historical but doesn't actually match what Shapiro sees on the ground. So when Shapiro notes "I was part of that sergeant’s fictive world," we should read it both ways: "I was part" but that world is "fictive."
In the final part, Shapiro is on a mission to bomb Germany; and unlike the other sections, where Shapiro pulls together multiple images or stories, this section is purely given over to the repeated experience of the bombing run. Which culminates in the final (and only for this section) mention of media:
How to believe all that happened,Check out the flatness of that--movie, tv, other life--as if life was just another sort of story we tell. And after all that confusion about history and story, who can say otherwise?
as in a movie, a tv drama, or some other life.
Bonus: What's up with Shapiro's "little friend, little friend" interjection? Is it a reference to Randall Jarrell's 1945 book of poetry of that name?
Friday, July 26, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 94: Countee Cullen, The Ballad of the Brown Girl (#166)
Countee Cullen, "The Ballad of the Brown Girl" (1927) from Countee Cullen: Collected Poems:
This pdf will only be available until August 2013, so if you like ballads about death--Nick Cave, I'm talking to you--go read this now. Because it's very easy to read this as a simple, old-fashioned murder ballad: man loves one girl, but another girl is rich, so his mom tells him to marry the rich girl; then, at the wedding, when the man fails to protect the rich girl (now wife) from the beloved girl's insult, the rich girl kills the beloved; and then the man kills the rich girl and himself. The hero, of course, is the Conquerer Worm.
That's one way to read it--not the Conquerer Worm, but that it's a typical murder ballad. But there is another, which is as a race murder ballad. While I kept making the distinction between rich girl and loved girl, the poem makes the distinction between the fair girl and the dark girl (or the brown girl). And yes, it is easy to imagine an old English ballad making that distinction; but fair vs. dark takes on somewhat different meaning in America--especially when written by W. E. B. Dubois's son-in-law. (Temporary son-in-law, but still.) When the poem mentions "blue grass," it's hard not to think of the American south (even if the dude is named Lord Thomas). So the final disposition of the bodies--white woman at the husband's side, brown woman at his feet--can be read in either way: true love being given pride of place after death; or the black mistress taking second place to the white woman who should've been the wife.
Yet I almost find this poem more interesting because of the arguments among the black arts community about what it would mean to make "black art." Cullen takes an old style story--even saying in the subtitle that this is old--and gives it a few twists to make it speak to a racially divided nation; whereas Langston Hughes is out arguing that black art needs to speak to a different tradition; while George Schuyler is out arguing that "black art" is less about being black and more about economic class conditions.
This pdf will only be available until August 2013, so if you like ballads about death--Nick Cave, I'm talking to you--go read this now. Because it's very easy to read this as a simple, old-fashioned murder ballad: man loves one girl, but another girl is rich, so his mom tells him to marry the rich girl; then, at the wedding, when the man fails to protect the rich girl (now wife) from the beloved girl's insult, the rich girl kills the beloved; and then the man kills the rich girl and himself. The hero, of course, is the Conquerer Worm.
That's one way to read it--not the Conquerer Worm, but that it's a typical murder ballad. But there is another, which is as a race murder ballad. While I kept making the distinction between rich girl and loved girl, the poem makes the distinction between the fair girl and the dark girl (or the brown girl). And yes, it is easy to imagine an old English ballad making that distinction; but fair vs. dark takes on somewhat different meaning in America--especially when written by W. E. B. Dubois's son-in-law. (Temporary son-in-law, but still.) When the poem mentions "blue grass," it's hard not to think of the American south (even if the dude is named Lord Thomas). So the final disposition of the bodies--white woman at the husband's side, brown woman at his feet--can be read in either way: true love being given pride of place after death; or the black mistress taking second place to the white woman who should've been the wife.
Yet I almost find this poem more interesting because of the arguments among the black arts community about what it would mean to make "black art." Cullen takes an old style story--even saying in the subtitle that this is old--and gives it a few twists to make it speak to a racially divided nation; whereas Langston Hughes is out arguing that black art needs to speak to a different tradition; while George Schuyler is out arguing that "black art" is less about being black and more about economic class conditions.
Short Story Read-Aloud, Week 20
Clarkesworld
E. Lily Yiu, "The Cartographer Wasps and the Anarchist Bees": Told at sort of a macro level with a bunch of episodes: some wasps make maps, get evicted by humans; the wasps start a new colony, conquer and enslave some bees; some servant bees learn anarchism from the wasps and start their own colony; the humans come back and kill off the wasps; the bees who lived under the wasps have to figure out their own way; while the anarchist bees die off.
Escape Artists (Escape Pod, Podcastle, Pseudopod)
Eric Czuleger, "Immortal L.A.": Something about vampires. The audio level was pretty low and indistinct, so I couldn't hear the story.
Lightspeed and Nightmare
Megan Arkenberg, "The Huntsman": Which Huntsman? Just kidding--it's another fairy-tale-inflected/rewritten, a sort of modernization take-off of Snow White's Huntsman character. Frankly, I didn't see the point of this story: the huntsman isn't a very interesting character and I'm not sure what themes this revision is meant to explore.
Cast of Wonders (Protecting Project Pulp, Tales to Terrify, Starship Sofa)
Martin Mundt, "The Day I Didn’t Meet Christopher Walken": A humorous story about the author getting caught in a robbery at a convenience store--at which point Christopher Walken comes in, absorbs all the attention by acting weird, and dismembers the robbers. Would've been funnier if shorter, but a nice mix of comedy, horror, and surreality.
Nina Kiriki Hoffman, "My Tears Have Been My Meat": An abused woman poisons her husband, but despite the warnings of her dead daughter, the woman stays around long enough to see the abuser (powered by tears and blood) rise from the dead. The soul-sucking zombie might be a little hoary, but it's enlivened (ba-dum-ching) by being tied to something serious, like abuse.
Kim Newman, "Illimitable Dominion": Another light story--though a little long--about a guy in the 60's with a chimp who wants to get Edgar Allan Poe's "Rue Morgue" made into a movie; and who inadvertently kicks off a Poe craze. A nice blending of real movie history with some alternate history.
Stephen Volk, "After the Ape": After King Kong, Ann Darrow is distraught and drunk; and invites a waiter in the hotel to visit with her for a while. Both have wildly disparate ideas about what's going on. A fine parallel tale/unofficial sequel idea, but a little draggy.
Tim Powers, "The Way Down the Hill": A secret society of immortals gets reincarnated whenever they die; except they do so by pushing out other souls into the dark void. So when a few immortals try to start a conspiracy, the protagonist exposes them and says it's time for them to start dying normal deaths.
Matt Hughes, "A Passion Ploy": Alien artifact fascinates people in the criminal underground; turns out to be alien seedpod that wants to plant itself in people. Entertaining voice with interesting killer plant twist.
Eric Taylor, "Kali": A man's fiancee is under the guardianship of a widow who is in thrall to--gasp!--a Hindu. There's some very awkward and amateur exposition here--like the fiancee explaining her history to her beau. Not worth it.
E. Lily Yiu, "The Cartographer Wasps and the Anarchist Bees": Told at sort of a macro level with a bunch of episodes: some wasps make maps, get evicted by humans; the wasps start a new colony, conquer and enslave some bees; some servant bees learn anarchism from the wasps and start their own colony; the humans come back and kill off the wasps; the bees who lived under the wasps have to figure out their own way; while the anarchist bees die off.
Escape Artists (Escape Pod, Podcastle, Pseudopod)
Eric Czuleger, "Immortal L.A.": Something about vampires. The audio level was pretty low and indistinct, so I couldn't hear the story.
Lightspeed and Nightmare
Megan Arkenberg, "The Huntsman": Which Huntsman? Just kidding--it's another fairy-tale-inflected/rewritten, a sort of modernization take-off of Snow White's Huntsman character. Frankly, I didn't see the point of this story: the huntsman isn't a very interesting character and I'm not sure what themes this revision is meant to explore.
Cast of Wonders (Protecting Project Pulp, Tales to Terrify, Starship Sofa)
Martin Mundt, "The Day I Didn’t Meet Christopher Walken": A humorous story about the author getting caught in a robbery at a convenience store--at which point Christopher Walken comes in, absorbs all the attention by acting weird, and dismembers the robbers. Would've been funnier if shorter, but a nice mix of comedy, horror, and surreality.
Nina Kiriki Hoffman, "My Tears Have Been My Meat": An abused woman poisons her husband, but despite the warnings of her dead daughter, the woman stays around long enough to see the abuser (powered by tears and blood) rise from the dead. The soul-sucking zombie might be a little hoary, but it's enlivened (ba-dum-ching) by being tied to something serious, like abuse.
Kim Newman, "Illimitable Dominion": Another light story--though a little long--about a guy in the 60's with a chimp who wants to get Edgar Allan Poe's "Rue Morgue" made into a movie; and who inadvertently kicks off a Poe craze. A nice blending of real movie history with some alternate history.
Stephen Volk, "After the Ape": After King Kong, Ann Darrow is distraught and drunk; and invites a waiter in the hotel to visit with her for a while. Both have wildly disparate ideas about what's going on. A fine parallel tale/unofficial sequel idea, but a little draggy.
Tim Powers, "The Way Down the Hill": A secret society of immortals gets reincarnated whenever they die; except they do so by pushing out other souls into the dark void. So when a few immortals try to start a conspiracy, the protagonist exposes them and says it's time for them to start dying normal deaths.
Matt Hughes, "A Passion Ploy": Alien artifact fascinates people in the criminal underground; turns out to be alien seedpod that wants to plant itself in people. Entertaining voice with interesting killer plant twist.
Eric Taylor, "Kali": A man's fiancee is under the guardianship of a widow who is in thrall to--gasp!--a Hindu. There's some very awkward and amateur exposition here--like the fiancee explaining her history to her beau. Not worth it.
Thursday, July 25, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 93: Bret Harte, The Legend of Monte del Diablo (#132)
Bret Harte, "The Legend of Monte del Diablo" (1863) from American Fantastic Tales: Terror and the Uncanny from Poe to the Pulps:
Do people still read Bret Harte? As one my fields in grad school was 19th-century American literature, I know I read him; and I feel like his name comes up in some high school attempts to find fun older literature. But, by contrast, he doesn't have his own LoA book; and he might be the first named person I've run across that I can say that about. I mean, you expect Twain to have some books; you don't expect John Hay to have an LoA entry; and Bret Harte, well, he could go either way.
After reading this story, I feel less like Bret Harte needs his own collection. First, he only has a handful of stories that are his best and most famous--“The Luck of the Roaring Camp” and “The Outcasts of Poker Flat,” both mentioned in the LoA page. Second, this story is less interesting than those; it's presented as a legend for why Mt. Diablo (outside San Francisco) got its name, which, surprise, has to do with the devil tempting a good monk during the time of the Spanish missions. It's not very interesting, I think; and for once, I seem to be on the same page as the Atlantic's editor, who said it "failed to interest." (Though he still ran it.)
The main story may not be super interesting, but there are some interesting grace notes here. There's a lot of landscape description, which doesn't move the story very much, but does, in some small way, set up the disappointment of the monk: here he is, traveling in this pristine wilderness, thinking about saving the souls of all the Indians, when the Devil gives him a glimpse of the wilderness-destroying industry that will come from the East and that will kick out the Spanish missions. Well, can't argue with that since it, you know, happened. But I also can't really get into the struggle. Do I prefer conquistador gentility or Anglo industrial rapine? That's like reading a story called "The Tiger or the Tiger?"--I can't really see any upside here.
Do people still read Bret Harte? As one my fields in grad school was 19th-century American literature, I know I read him; and I feel like his name comes up in some high school attempts to find fun older literature. But, by contrast, he doesn't have his own LoA book; and he might be the first named person I've run across that I can say that about. I mean, you expect Twain to have some books; you don't expect John Hay to have an LoA entry; and Bret Harte, well, he could go either way.
After reading this story, I feel less like Bret Harte needs his own collection. First, he only has a handful of stories that are his best and most famous--“The Luck of the Roaring Camp” and “The Outcasts of Poker Flat,” both mentioned in the LoA page. Second, this story is less interesting than those; it's presented as a legend for why Mt. Diablo (outside San Francisco) got its name, which, surprise, has to do with the devil tempting a good monk during the time of the Spanish missions. It's not very interesting, I think; and for once, I seem to be on the same page as the Atlantic's editor, who said it "failed to interest." (Though he still ran it.)
The main story may not be super interesting, but there are some interesting grace notes here. There's a lot of landscape description, which doesn't move the story very much, but does, in some small way, set up the disappointment of the monk: here he is, traveling in this pristine wilderness, thinking about saving the souls of all the Indians, when the Devil gives him a glimpse of the wilderness-destroying industry that will come from the East and that will kick out the Spanish missions. Well, can't argue with that since it, you know, happened. But I also can't really get into the struggle. Do I prefer conquistador gentility or Anglo industrial rapine? That's like reading a story called "The Tiger or the Tiger?"--I can't really see any upside here.
Wednesday, July 24, 2013
Library of America Story of the Week Read-Along 92: Bettye Rice Hughes, A Negro Tourist in Dixie (#107)
Bettye Rice Hughes, "A Negro Tourist in Dixie" (1962) from Reporting Civil Rights: American Journalism 1941–1963:
I never get tired of hearing the argument that racism is over, which often goes something like this: because outright expressions of racism are looked down on or even illegal, everyone treats white and black people alike. Well, black Bettye Rice Hughes went for a bus ride through the South after inter-state segregation was outlawed, and she knows that racism isn't just about the law.
Hughes's short article summarizes ruthlessly, fitting six weeks of Southern bus travel into six pages, with telling anecdotes from various stops and general observations: the "White" and "Colored" parts of the restroom signs are covered up; white and black people still look oddly at the black woman who walks in the white people's restaurant. Some of the places she goes to solve this problem by having the one black worker coming to serve her; although my favorite anecdote might be the white waitress who agrees with some white woman that it's a shame to have to serve black people, and then, when she's alone with Hughes, starts up a totally normal conversation about where she's from, where she's going, etc.
Which makes it sound like the waitress is just someone trying to get along--she's not so big a racist that she'll object to serving Hughes; but she's not so much a protestor that she'll argue with the white patron. But we'll never really know what she is thinking, which is clear in Hughes's account for everyone she meets.
And that's the second-biggest trouble that Hughes seems to face, if we're counting the "subtle" racism of slight hostility and chilliness as her first-biggest trouble. (Again: according to a certain type of person, that doesn't count as racism since it doesn't involve the n-word.) That is, she gets through her experiment safely--but she's not really sure why. How bad is racism in the south after the Freedom Riders and the attacks by white supremacists? It's not good and more work needs to be done; but when we can't read other people's minds, it's hard to know what work to do.
I never get tired of hearing the argument that racism is over, which often goes something like this: because outright expressions of racism are looked down on or even illegal, everyone treats white and black people alike. Well, black Bettye Rice Hughes went for a bus ride through the South after inter-state segregation was outlawed, and she knows that racism isn't just about the law.
Hughes's short article summarizes ruthlessly, fitting six weeks of Southern bus travel into six pages, with telling anecdotes from various stops and general observations: the "White" and "Colored" parts of the restroom signs are covered up; white and black people still look oddly at the black woman who walks in the white people's restaurant. Some of the places she goes to solve this problem by having the one black worker coming to serve her; although my favorite anecdote might be the white waitress who agrees with some white woman that it's a shame to have to serve black people, and then, when she's alone with Hughes, starts up a totally normal conversation about where she's from, where she's going, etc.
Which makes it sound like the waitress is just someone trying to get along--she's not so big a racist that she'll object to serving Hughes; but she's not so much a protestor that she'll argue with the white patron. But we'll never really know what she is thinking, which is clear in Hughes's account for everyone she meets.
And that's the second-biggest trouble that Hughes seems to face, if we're counting the "subtle" racism of slight hostility and chilliness as her first-biggest trouble. (Again: according to a certain type of person, that doesn't count as racism since it doesn't involve the n-word.) That is, she gets through her experiment safely--but she's not really sure why. How bad is racism in the south after the Freedom Riders and the attacks by white supremacists? It's not good and more work needs to be done; but when we can't read other people's minds, it's hard to know what work to do.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)