Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Sockpuppets and being nice on twitter, part 2

In Part 1, I went over the urge to create a sockpuppet account to support your product (because we take consumption cues from peers and sometimes it's just you trying to flog your product by pretending to be a peer).

In Part 2, I want to talk about more honest ways to get your name out there in a positive way, largely focusing on being a nice person in public.

How often have conversations about Neil Gaiman included the info that he's a really nice guy? I'm guessing it approaches 100% because he's a real nice guy. (I once saw him give a talk in a small room and someone's cellphone went off and she took the call and he didn't like it but he didn't make a deal about it at all.)

We could probably make a pretty good list of artists who are nice vs. artists who are jerks: Scalzi, Saladin Ahmed, Brandon Sanderson--all nice people who engage with their public, in blogs (Scalzi), on Twitter (Ahmed), through podcasts (Sanderson). 

(By contrast, a friend went to a Robyn Hitchcock show; and the next day ran into him (at a White Stripes concert) and said what a great show it was and Robyn's response was "I know, I was there." Which might be fair, but isn't particularly nice.)

God knows I don't want a world where everyone is nice. But it is a pretty good method for getting your product consumed in some way. So, instead of sockpuppets pushing your work, you make sure that your target audience thinks of you in a fuzzy, warm way.

How?

Give them something free and show them that you're interested in them: blog, Twitter, podcast, even a webcomic. (I just bought Kate Beaton's book and I've bought from Dorothy Gambrell before because I love their comics and I wanted to give back.)

That last might be the most surprising: if you give away your product, you may be able to get something back. 

I wish we had some data on this, but for now, anecdata will have to do, so... have you ever been inclined to buy a product because the producer was nice?

Monday, February 6, 2012

Sockpuppets and being nice on twitter, part 1

As promised, here is a post on sockpuppets and being nice on Twitter--or on podcasts or at book fairs, etc.

Problem: how do you get people to consume your product? 

People usually (and used to) want to be like their idols and socially higher-ups; so if you have a beer that needs drinking, put it in the hands of a king (UK) or a movie star (USA), and some people will drink it as easily as that. (Or for the historical view: peasants dress up like merchants, merchants dress up like nobles--and nobles enact sumptuary laws to keep the lower orders from dressing/consuming like them.)

But what about if people start taking their cues from their equals and peers? 

Then you need to your target to be surrounded by people who consume your product. This is the world of buzz and viral marketing, where you (the PR company) hires an actor or actress to order a particular beer at a bar, and do so in a way that ensures that other people see you buying that beer (or talking up that movie or whatever the whatever). And then those people who saw the original consumer start consuming that way and then other people see those consumers, et al.

But let's say that you don't have a company--you're just one person with a book that you've self-published.

(I like beer as an example, but let's be honest: we're talking about books.) You could try to get your book noticed by juicing the sale numbers--getting all your friends and family to buy lots of copies so that the book was in the Top 10 bestsellers. (Because, believe me, being in the top 10 will lead to more purchases. Nothing succeeds like success.)

But that's expensive; maybe we can juice your numbers through some free method, like positive reviews. But what if you're the only person who likes (or has read) your book?

Sockpuppets

Orson Scott Card's Ender's Game does a nice job portraying the Internets and forums, and how unscrupulous little monsters could use the anonymity of the web to juice the numbers/take over the world. That is, two super-bright kids start up important pseudonyms to get some ideas out there; but they set up alternate accounts/names to support those primary accounts.

And people do this in real life, especially on Amazon, where writers can feel free to post positive reviews under alternative names. It's not always easy to identify these false positive reviews, though I recently read a book for review which seems to have some sockpuppet-written reviews both on Amazon and Goodreads. My clues?

  1. Verbal similarity: the reviews sound very similar to each other and the book.
  2. No other reviews: on Amazon, these positive reviews were written by accounts that had no other reviews.
  3. Private accounts with unlikely average ratings: on Goodreads, there are positive reviews written by people who have a) hidden their accounts and b) have average review ratings of 5 stars--so these look like accounts that are used mostly to talk up books.
  4. Hyperbole: these reviews can't say enough good about this book that, to put it succinctly, no editor liked enough to publish.
The underdog needs sympathy

There's something I like about self-published authors--they are plucky and self-confident. (Note: Yeah, there's condescension mixed in there, but if it weren't for condescension, I wouldn't have any descension at all.) But when these self-published underdogs try to trick readers into reading their stuff, you run the real risk of losing sympathy and goodwill--which are arguably more important than good reviews.

Have you run into instances of sockpuppetry?

More tomorrow. Or as the book I finished ended: "to be continued."
Cite: Sockpuppets (TV Tropes); Sockpuppets (Wiki)

Saturday, February 4, 2012

A day arguing with conservatives

For some reason, I've been in a nostalgic mood this week. You know the type of the mood, where you go searching out old blog posts, reading old emails from exes, revisiting conservative websites that you used to haunt. You know how it is.

The inciting incident for me visiting this conservative website this week was the Komen-Planned Parenthood dust-up, which got a lot of good news out there eventually: a) Komen's not a great charity; b) Planned Parenthood offers lots of services (check out this collection of stories from people who PP helped out); and c) immediate pushback gets things done.

So maybe I was feeling a little self-satisfied with Komen's reversal of the bad policy that would preclude PP from getting grants. And so I visited this website that specializes in combatting liberal bias in the media to see what they would have to say.

And that was part of my Friday down the drain, replaying Twain's "Sixth-Century Political Economy" from Connecticut Yankee: just arguing the same things over and over.

The weird thing for me was that it took a while for people to come out and just say that they were opposed to abortions in all circumstances and that no good services (like STD testing or breast cancer exams) would make up for that sin.

I don't know whether to be hopeful that I could at least engage in an argument about statistics; or sad that people would engage in an argument about statistics when no numbers could ever satisfy their philosophical/theological conditions.

Friday, February 3, 2012

Politics every day is bad for your health.

I have no data to back this up; but it seems clear to me that paying attention every day to the doings of idiots, sociopaths, and idiotic sociopaths must be bad for the heart. (Both in the "blood pressure" sense and in the "hope for humanity" sense.)

What's really aggravating about political news for close watchers is that things happen every day, but very few things turn out to be important. Now, it's easy to imagine bad laws being adopted in the middle of the night when no one is looking; and that's stuff we should pay attention to.

And the whole Komen-Planned Parenthood kerfuffle is another example of something that's worth paying attention to. (In the same way that Netflix's split was worth paying attention to: it's a bad decision and some pushback from clients and donors might be enough to reverse the decision.)

But Ann Coulter saying something mean and dumb? Not news. Number-free essays on how the unemployment numbers have changed? Need data--and a grain of salt.. Endless pontificating about which Republican will win which state? Just wait and see.

So, as with all things, I'd recommend moderation when paying attention to politics daily.

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Chicago II: This Time It's Personal

Rather than go through every day of my recent trip to Chicago--which I could, because I took crazy detailed notes--I want to talk about the broad outlines and some thoughts about the difference between Chicago and San Angelo.

I spent most of my time in Chicago eating, filling up at restaurants that don't exist down in SA: Thai, artisanal, vegan. I went to almost all my old favorite places, which was fun. But a lot of my memory of those places is going with Sarah. So, I was glad to hit up Lula with a friend, but that used to be a place where Sarah and I could sneak a Monday brunch before she went to work.

Can you go home again? About half-way, I'd say.

Hilariously or painfully, I stayed with two friends who were deep in the throes of academic preparation, which was a blast from the past for me. I offered to read one's paper, but I don't know how helpful I was. At the same time, I had work of my own: the second book I got to review for Kirkus. (More on that later, when I discuss "Sock puppets and being nice on twitter.")

So, trying to stay warm while reading--that's about 95% of my years in Chicago. So I miss the food of Chicago, but this winter weather here is pretty unbeatable. Well, that may not be true: when Sarah and I went to Austin for New Year's, the weather there was even better. Let's wait until we survive a summer here before we celebrate.

Besides eating and reading/working, I spent most of my time talking to people and watching things: Flight of the Conchords standup, the first episode of Luther, Hugo in 3D, and Trollhunter. (Maybe I'll do a roundup of those.) And drinking after my show at a nearby divey bar.

Judging from that, not only can I go home again, but I'm home wherever I go, as long as I have Netflix.

The best part of my trip was catching up with friends. I know a few people here in SA, but it's not quite the same; on top of that, an old friend of mine recently got back in touch (years after our friendship exploded messily--and that's all I'll probably say about that), so I've been thinking about friends and social networks a lot. Basically, it boils down to this: I'd like to live in a place where there are lots of people to hug.

Unfortunately (and fortunately), a lot of my Chicago friends have leads on jobs that will take them out of Chicago. So how will we see each other then?

The worst part of my trip was probably when my flight from Chicago to Dallas was delayed, so I just barely missed my flight to San Angelo--which was the last flight of the day. Luckily, my schedule was flexible enough for me to spend the night there; though I wish I had a car or some way to get to the fun parts of Dallas. I've been assured they exist.

January blogging recap

I made a deal with my friend Adrianne to blog every other day in January, partly to keep myself writing, partly to get her to write. (No pressure, Adrianne, but I enjoy your writing very much.) So, how did I do--and what did I write about?

Out of 31 days, 18 posts.

Of 18 posts, posts on:

  • Sketch comedy: 6
  • Politics: 4
  • Texas: 2
  • Meta: 2
  • Writing: 2
  • Podcasts: 1
  • Movies: 1
Of those posts, posted on:

  • Sunday: 4/5
  • Monday: 1/5
  • Tuesday: 5/5
  • Wednesday: 2/4
  • Thursday: 2/4
  • Friday: 4/4
  • Saturday: 0/4
So I really took advantage of my sketch show to pad out my count this January. (Though, to be fair, it was also on my mind; and part of me wonders if day-to-day political watching is actually counter-productive. More on that later.)

It's also curious to me that the best days for blogging are Sunday, Tuesday, and Friday. I don't know what I was doing on Saturdays that kept me from blogging, but I clearly felt bad about it on Sunday. (Or, more likely, I wrote out some of a post on Saturday night and then posted it on Sunday.)

The real mystery isn't Sunday or Tuesday--it seems clear that I missed Sunday and Monday, thus making me feel like I should post on Sunday and Tuesday. But what's with Friday? Anticipatory guilt?

Anyway, now that we're in February, I hope to write less about sketch comedy and more about other things, like politics (feh) and hobbies (meh) and secret personal histories (weh). What will you be up to in February?

Tuesday, January 31, 2012

So many things to talk about!

I've felt this way before--I've felt that I had lots of topics that I wanted to cover on my blog--and it's fizzled out in the past. I make up lists of possible topics; I pepper old posts with promises that the next post will cover topic X; and then... nothing.

But this time I mean it! Upcoming post topics include
  • something on Florida probably;
  • a recap of January's blogging, along with a secret or not-so-secret pact;
  • a penultimate comment on what I learned turning sketches on paper into sketches in the real world (hopefully with accompanying video)...;
  • to be followed much later by a final comment on the show and future writing-related plans;
  • a recap of my trip to Chicago;
  • and possibly more! Or less! Let's not commit ourselves too early.
I would cover one of those topics, but I'm a little tired and achy from my trip back from Chi. See, I was supposed to get in last night, but I missed my flight, so they sent me this early morning. And all my lack of sleep and water has finally caught up with me.

But tomorrow we'll get back to real blogging. Or ersatz blogging. We'll see.

Sunday, January 29, 2012

Post-Mortem on "Unicorns, The Middle Class, And Other Mythical Creatures"

I've seen my show twice: on opening night, thanks to a friend's Facetime-enabled iPhone; and on closing night, from the booth, with the rest of the writers laughing at our own material (still!) and with the director providing free commentary on what hit and what missed.

From my minor experience on stage--you know, in high school--I feel like there's a 50/50 chance with closing night: it's either a finely-tuned machine; or it's the show where the cast brings out their personal, untested tweaks because they're bored or where the cast just stumbles over lines because they're thinking about their next shows.

 I will have more to say about this show after our official post-mortem with the director and the other writers; but from what I heard from the other writers, it sounds like closing night was messier than some other nights. For instance, in one of my sketches, there's a series of jokes about bad scripts, and the actors jumped to the final, longest joke. But it all still worked, I thought. (Friends were there and they seemed to like it. And, heck, we all laughed.) So even if this closing night was a little messy, it was still a lot of fun.

Especially because I got to go up after the performance and take a bow. We got diplomas and nice writing pads; and friends told me that my uncomfortable smile didn't look forced at all. So, all in all, teleconferencing in from Texas was hard; and I might be more interested in some of the other writing classes (for instance, there's a class that seems more professionally useful, like writing a tv spec); but the transition from writing sketches to putting them on was very educational. So what did I learn? More on that after I think about it.

Friday, January 27, 2012

You're getting Chicago and you're getting Chicago, everyone's getting Chicago

I've been trying to post every other day at least, but I've recently fallen off the wagon because of my trip to Chicago. It's not that Chicago is inherently distracting; but coming back has been a strange mix of shocking and boring. (It's not that Chicago is boring--it's that I'm boring. Remember your Buckaroo Banzai: Every where you go, there you are.)

Wednesday was mostly travel, flying from San Angelo, through Dallas, to O'Hare. I'm staying with busy friends, so we mostly ate and hung around. Luckily, besides my self-medication (2 games of insane-level Sudoku), I also have a giant book to read for a Kirkus review. So I have plenty to keep me busy.

Until today, that is, when I have the closing show of my cowritten sketch revue. As you may know, I've been flogging the hell out of that show on Facebook. ("Flogging the hell out of" = posting twice a week. I just don't like self-promotion, so it feels like hell.) And I had no compunction about telling people to come.

Until I realized that some of my best friends in Chicago are going to come tonight--they bought tickets and everything. (Note: I don't get any of that money. Damn.) So now I've got friends coming to see the show and I care about their opinions. So now I'm nervous and can feel my heart fluttering.

Alternately, I could have an elevated heart rate because of the coffee that I'm drinking.

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Blue sky (or, Just taking up space)

I always forget to bring my phone or camera with me when I go out on walks with my dog, so I miss the chance to take pictures of anthropological interest--the bumper sticker "Jesus Didn't Tap," the pile of garbage bags full of Bud Light cans, etc. (Curious about "Jesus Didn't Tap"? I'll tell you more about that soon.)

But every once in a while, I do have my phone with me--though never my camera. (Let's be honest, for a certain portion of the population, separate "cameras" don't exist anymore. This obviously doesn't include people who attended the Salt Institute for Documentary Studies or paparazzi; but for people who used to use point-and-shoot cameras, the phone camera has pretty well replaced that. True or false?)

Anyway, in case you were more interested in natural rather than built or anthropological environment, here is a tree, denuded of much of its leaves, in front of a blue-blue-blue sky, which is mostly what we have here.

How does this make you feel?

It makes me thirsty. (But, to be honest, I'm posting this because a) I want to try out Picasa's blogging function and b) I'm getting ready for my trip to Chicago.)

Posted by Picasa

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Nice Whig!; or, Are you ready to (have a new) party (system)?

It's really hard to look around us and realize that we live in a contingent world--we take for granted many things that might easily have been different. And so, for a presentist, it's hard to remember that things were once different and things might once again be different in a future.

So, when you look around at the Republican and Democratic Parties, it's sometimes hard to remember that these weren't always the major parties in America.

Political historians break down American history into several big chunks, which roughly look like:

  1. First Party System
    1. When: 1792 - 1824
    2. Who: The Federalist Party vs. the Republican/Democratic-Republican Party
    3. ...or: Hamilton vs. Jefferson
    4. Why: Federal power vs. State power; Industrial power vs. Agrarian power; British ties vs. French ties
    5. How did it end?: Hamilton had some success with the federal bank, but the next generation arose with new issues
  2. Second Party System
    1. When: 1828 - 1854
    2. Who: The Democratic Party vs. the Whig Party
    3. ...or: Jackson vs. Henry Clay
    4. Why: New South/West vs. Old Northeast power; Jackson's anti-central bank issues vs. Whig's modernizing/industrializing interest; the Mob vs. the Rich
    5. How did it end?: Whig ideas on modernization become mainstream but the Whig party falls apart due to slavery.
  3. Third Party System
    1. When: 1854 - 1890s
    2. Who:  The Republican Party vs. the Democratic Party
    3. ... or: Carpetbaggers and Scalawags vs. Southern Redeemers, Lutherans vs. Catholics, etc.
    4. Why: Civil War, Reconstruction, even more Manifest Destiny.
    5. How did it end?: Once again, new issues bring about a political realignment (rise of labor unions, series of bad recessions), including the rise of third party Populist movements.
  4. Fourth Party System
    1. When: 1890s - 1932
    2. Who:  The Republican Party vs. the Democratic Party
    3. ... or: Calvin Coolidge triumphant! 
    4. Why: Trust-busting and big business, government inspection of meat production
    5. How did it end?: Prohibition put strains on certain political alliances, but the Great Depression does it in. The Democratic Party begins to lose the Southern Redeemer stink. Blacks and college graduates start voting Democratic.
  5. Fifth Party System
    1. When: 1933 - ? (1960, end of New Deal Coalition; 1980, formation of the Moral Majority)
    2. Who:  The Republican Party vs. the Democratic Party
    3. ... or: FDR vs. Reagan
    4. Why: Social security
    5. How did it end?: Civil Rights Era drives final wedge between Democratic Party and white Southerners, including rise of Dixiecrat segregationist third party (1948); post-war baby and jobs boom ends up with spoiled Reaganites crashing the party in the 1980s.
When you look at a rough history like that, you probably see some big consistencies--conservative, agrarian, anti-bank tendencies vs. modernizing, industrialization, pro-bank tendencies. But we should also see the differences. (A good gauge for this is probably your first thoughts: in the First Party System, I'm Hamiltonian--I like a strong banking system; in the Fifth Party System, I'm all for bank regulation. I guess the difference is I like a strong central bank, but I don't like cocaine-fueled bankers. It's a subtle distinction.)

So here's really why I'm bringing all this up: with the Republican party pulled in three ways--Romney, the technocrat financier from the East; Gingrich, the angry populist from the Southeast (born PA, served GA); and Paul, the libertarian philosopher from Texas--do you think we're going to see a party breakdown and realignment ushering in a new party system?

Probably not, right: all the other party realignments coincided with/were spurred on by new issues emerging from the background. Slavery was always an issue for some people, but it became more of a dividing issue in the 1850s and 1860s with the admittance of more states into the union--and that's what led to the breakdown of the party system. 

But today, all the issues that are coming up are pretty much the same as in 2008--social security, culture war, future panic. In 2008, the Republican party, in some disarray, tried to energize the base through a mixed ticket: old line pragmatist McCain and firebrand Palin. (I mean, that's the way they were packaged; these days, it's hard to look back at McCain as anything other than a doddering senile tumor full of rage.)

The fractures this year seem worse--c.f. Gingrinch's attack on Bain, which has to sound like socialism to some people. But I'm expecting some amicable patch-up this year that leaves more people unsatisfied both with the selection and with losing. (Which I think they will, baring some terrible Euro breakdown.)

But once more and more people get unsatisfied? Maybe we're do for a realignment--not so much a third party, but for a sloughing off of some voters into the other party.

Friday, January 20, 2012

Science Friday's Callers: A Study in Derailing Conversation

OK, maybe I'm being a little hyperbolic in describing Science Friday's callers as derailing conversation; but it seems clear to me that these callers do not add value to the show.

If you're unfamiliar with Science Friday, it's a two-hour NPR show about lots of science-related issues, from new studies (how yogurt helps); to new discoveries (kraken kill dinosaurs and arrange their bones?); to ongoing arguments (is Dissociative Identity Disorder real?); to the origins of scientific words (who was Bunsen and why did he want to burn things?); to science-in-culture discussions (how realistic was Contagion?).

So, that sounds pretty interesting, right? As the cherry on top, Science Friday is hosted by Ira Flatow (thanks, Wikipedia!), who was the host of Newton's Apple, which is one of the guideposts of my childhood (and the reason why I love Rube Goldberg machines).

But Science Friday includes times to call-in and discuss these complex scientific issues or ask clarifying questions of the experts--and these calls really lower the value of the show for me.

Often, someone will call in to ask a clarifying question on something that the scientist said which seemed pretty clear the first time--but then, if one person is confused, it's likely that others are confused as well. So, these question-askers take time, but you can't resent them too much.

More aggravating are those callers who call in to grind their ax--anti-vaccine activists, global warming deniers, other members of the public who want to comment on science that they don't understand. I once heard a guy call in to ask Ira and guest if the internal structure of crystals proved that the whole universe vibrated in harmony--and the show was only tangentially on geology.

And what's worst is that Flatow cannot or will not cut people off or hang up on them for the longest time. He just lets people go on about how cavemen hunted dinosaurs and blah blah blah.

Maybe we should chip in a few bucks to Science Friday so that they can hire an extra producer to screen these calls. Or get some lessons for Flatow on how to be more assertive.

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

Wikipedia goes dark for 24 hours--great protest or best protest ever?

In a few hours (oh god, is it Eastern, Central, or Pacific?), Wikipedia will go dark for 24 hours to protest SOPA/PIPA, bills before Congress that everyone who likes communication dislikes. The only people who like those bills are IP-owning corporations (which, sure, they're people, right?).

Over the past few weeks, SOPA/PIPA have been altered a bit to make them less onerous on people, but they're still bad bills and potentially disruptive to the Enlightenment project that Wikipedia is engaged in (i.e., spreading information, preferably correct information, but let's remember that Diderot's Encyclopedie wasn't 100% accurate. The important thing is the corrigibility of the information: the project is the accumulation itself--this is science that we're engaged in, not theology).

I don't want to get deep into SOPA/PIPA, I just want to give some props to Wikipedia for coming up with a protest that's gotten attention and will continue to get attention. And what a great protest it is: it's a direct inquiry to users of Wikipedia, asking if this is the sort of world they want to live in. Do you want to live in a world without Wikipedia? Sure, we all joke about how annoying it is that some students use Wikipedia as a single-stop plagiarism store; or how they think it's the alpha and omega of research.

But all joking aside, Wikipedia is a huge resource that I use all the time. (Note to self: donate more to Wikipedia.) It won't be fun tomorrow, to go through 24 hours without Wikipedia, but I'd rather go without Wikipedia for a day to ensure that it survives the ever-oncoming copyright-holders onslaught.